The Premier League table now gives Enzo Maresca something concrete to chase. Arsenal are three points clear of Manchester City after Kai Havertz’s 16th-minute goal beat Liverpool 1-0 at Anfield on Sunday, 1 November. City had left that opening after losing to Brighton at home.
Michael Carrick has a more immediate problem. United’s 2-0 defeat at Chelsea followed a first half in which they looked capable of winning. City also lost 1-0 despite creating chances. It’s tempting to package both results as a Manchester crisis, but the work awaiting the two managers is quite different.
Carrick needs more than an encouraging first half
United had chances at Stamford Bridge and a Matheus Cunha goal ruled out for offside. Carrick was entitled to recognize that first half’s quality. His post-match admission that games had unraveled too often was more revealing, because it acknowledged a pattern that another good spell could not resolve.
Morgan Rogers ran through to score in the 50th minute. Lisandro Martinez later received a second yellow card after the incident involving Wesley Fofana that brought Chelsea a penalty, converted by Cole Palmer. United lost defensive control, then a player, leaving Carrick little opportunity to recover the afternoon.
The response has to include what happens immediately after conceding. United cannot afford for disappointment to alter their spacing or turn the next defensive challenge into a reckless one. A manager can rehearse a shape and assign responsibilities. The evidence that those instructions survive a setback has to come during the match.
Nine games without a win in any competition makes that urgent. Carrick’s position will remain under scrutiny until United can turn their better passages into lasting performances.
Maresca must separate bad finishing from avoidable errors
City’s defeat came a week after their 2-1 loss at Aston Villa. Yasin Ayari’s early goal at the Etihad put them behind again, and Brighton protected the lead with key saves and committed defending. City’s missed opportunities mattered, but Maresca also acknowledged the avoidable goals his team had been conceding.
That gives the coach a decision about how much to adjust. Adding attackers would not automatically cure poor finishing and could thin the defensive cover. Before changing the structure, City need to establish whether their existing movement is giving the right players clean chances, and whether the players behind the attack are ready for possession to change.
Maresca has grounds to resist a wholesale rethink after City won their opening seven league matches. He has less reason to rely on the idea that luck will change. Two defeats are enough to demand corrections, even if they do not prove the system has failed.
Arsenal make the opening count at Anfield
Arsenal supplied the weekend’s most useful comparison. They regained possession as Liverpool tried to play out, then worked the ball through Declan Rice for Havertz’s close-range finish. Liverpool threatened when Florian Wirtz hit the woodwork, but Arsenal held on to their lead.
They didn’t need to dominate every phase. Mikel Arteta’s side took their chance and protected the result, ending a league winless run at Anfield that stretched back to 2012. Carrick needs that reliability under pressure. Maresca needs to recover it without sacrificing City’s attacking threat. Arsenal have made both tasks harder by refusing to waste available points.